EnduraUmb-I asked about 2 years ago
Negative rating because asking why a channel was forced closed?
Hi how to fix a negative rating just for asking a question?
https://lightningnetwork.plus/swaps/7626
I opened the channel and later replaced by a bigger one so swap requirements fullfilled.
Then the channel was forced closed (to my knowledge from the remote side) - it was also confirmed by the channelpartner. I asked to reopen the channel and instead of an explaination the comment confirming that "the channel was closed" was deleted and I got a negative rating.
This kind of behaviour is a bit strange - unfortunaltely there is not private communication available here so I had to comment and now ask in public. I was assuming a technical issue. I would have even reopend the channel in case the root cause is on my side and it is ensured that it will not be closed again.
BTW as I am pretty new to LN - forced closed is done by remote side right (or on restauration via a channel backup)? At least channels that are closed by me and opened by me () a "cooperatively closed". Or in other words how to find out who/what triggered the closing?
Note: UmbrelGuy369 node lost ~50 channels the last few days...
https://lightningnetwork.plus/swaps/7626
I opened the channel and later replaced by a bigger one so swap requirements fullfilled.
Then the channel was forced closed (to my knowledge from the remote side) - it was also confirmed by the channelpartner. I asked to reopen the channel and instead of an explaination the comment confirming that "the channel was closed" was deleted and I got a negative rating.
This kind of behaviour is a bit strange - unfortunaltely there is not private communication available here so I had to comment and now ask in public. I was assuming a technical issue. I would have even reopend the channel in case the root cause is on my side and it is ensured that it will not be closed again.
BTW as I am pretty new to LN - forced closed is done by remote side right (or on restauration via a channel backup)? At least channels that are closed by me and opened by me () a "cooperatively closed". Or in other words how to find out who/what triggered the closing?
Note: UmbrelGuy369 node lost ~50 channels the last few days...
8 Comments
AkuMa wrote about 2 years ago
I am in the same situation but I not sure the guy you opened to can give you negative ratings. Ask the guy that opened to you
EnduraUmb-I wrote about 2 years ago
C rates B, B rates A, A rates C. You rate always to the one that should open a channel to you.
AkuMa wrote about 2 years ago
Oh you are right.
Weird that he gave you a negative rating, when he was the one that closed, unless you closed it by accident and not realizing it
Weird that he gave you a negative rating, when he was the one that closed, unless you closed it by accident and not realizing it
EnduraUmb-I wrote about 2 years ago
In the comment he confirmed that he closed it and then deleted the comment (but I got it as automatic mail) and rated me negative after I have reposted his comment.
Strange behaviour but I can only speculate about reasons...
Strange behaviour but I can only speculate about reasons...
AkuMa wrote about 2 years ago
How much did it cost you? So weird
MelonLND wrote about 2 years ago
I had the same thing happen from the same guy, even those he went AWOL for over a week and had nearly all of his 200+ channels disable him.
EnduraUmb-I wrote about 2 years ago
I am not chasing for money back - it is about stopping such behaviour.
Shire_Society_Federation wrote about 2 years ago
Perhaps people causing financial damages should bear the full logistical and financial cost to repair the damage? That's a good start.
Repeat violators could be held to a higher standard as well.
Repeat violators could be held to a higher standard as well.
Please login to post comments.